🏀 The Job

Opening brief, read aloud

You’ve just been hired as head coach of a basketball club. Every week the league office needs to know how many different team sheets you could possibly submit. There are different forms with different rules, and the office has been burned by formulas that only work for small rosters. This time every formula must be justified for any roster size, not just checked on a few.

1
Phase 1
Lineup or Squad
Task 1a

Roster: A, B, C, D, E. A lineup sheet names a different player for each of 3 positions (point guard, wing, center). How many lineup sheets?

Task 1b

A squad sheet lists only which 3 players make the team. How many squad sheets? Find it by listing.

Notation

\({}^{n}P_{r}\) = number of lineups (order matters). \({}^{n}C_{r}\) or \(\binom{n}{r}\) = number of squads (order does not matter). Work them out by hand.

Task 1c

Compare your answers: what is the relationship, and why? Test on 6 players (choose 3, then 4) and write a general formula for \({}^{n}C_{r}\).

Task 1d · Proof

Prove your relationship between \({}^{n}P_{r}\) and \({}^{n}C_{r}\) for any \(n\) and \(r\).

Task 1e

No calculator, show the cancellation: \({}^{8}P_{3}\), \(\binom{10}{3}\), \(\binom{12}{4}\).

Task 1f

What should \(\binom{n}{0}\) and \(\binom{n}{n}\) equal? Explain, and check against your formula. What does this say about \(0!\)?

2
Phase 2
The Mirror
Task 2a

Roster of 8. Find the number of squads of every size from 0 to 8, in a row. What do you notice? What is the total?

Task 2b · Proof

Prove the pattern for any \(n\) in two ways: in words (no algebra), and with your factorial formula.

Task 2c

No calculator: \(\binom{50}{48}\) and \(\binom{100}{98}\). Find \(n\) if \({}^{n}C_{3} = {}^{n}C_{12}\).

Task 2d · Generalize

The row \(1, 8, 28, 56, 70, 56, 28, 8, 1\) rises then falls. Simplify \({}^{n}C_{r+1} \div {}^{n}C_{r}\). Where does the row peak for any \(n\)? Prove it never rises again once it starts to fall.

Task 2e

Can \({}^{n}C_{a} = {}^{n}C_{b}\) with \(a \neq b\) for any reason other than your rule in 2b? Use 2d to settle it.

3
Phase 3
House Rules
Rule

Unless stated otherwise, every squad has exactly 5 players.

Task 3a

10 players, one of them the star S. (i) How many squads include S? (ii) How many exclude S? (iii) Compare with each other and with all squads of 5 from 10.

Task 3b

7 forwards and 5 guards. Every squad needs at least 2 guards. How many valid squads? Confirm with a completely different method.

Task 3c

11 players. Pick a squad of 5, then a captain and a different vice-captain from it. How many outcomes? Count two ways (squad first; roles first). Why must they agree?

Task 3d

A teammate says: 2 captains, then 3 others from 10, is \(\binom{10}{2}\times\binom{10}{3} = 5400\). What is wrong? Find the correct number.

Task 3e · Generalize

Choose \(a\) captains then \(b\) others from \(n\) people, no overlap. Write as a product of two choose-numbers, then as one factorial fraction. Why is it unchanged if \(a\) and \(b\) swap?

4
Phase 4
Captain’s Count
Task 4a · Proof

A team of \(k\) from \(n\), one named captain. Count (team, captain) outcomes two ways and conclude an equation linking \(k\binom{n}{k}\) to a choose-number with \(n-1\) and \(k-1\). Check on \(n=8,\ k=4\).

Task 4b · Proof

A roster of \(n\) may pick a squad of any size (none, or everyone). Count all possible squads two ways: by size, and player by player. What does this say about the sum of a row? Compare with 2a.

🚀 Challenge

(i) Every squad of \(r\) either includes the star S or not. Prove \(\binom{n}{r} = \binom{n-1}{r-1} + \binom{n-1}{r}\) and say how it relates to 3a. (ii) Prove that for \(n \ge 1\), exactly half of the \(2^n\) squads have an even number of players.